Nickel Plate District Neighborhood
Young professionals, couples, and families who want walkability
The Vibe: The Nickel Plate District is the most walkable in the city. It has a wonderful mixed-use center with restaurants and boutique shops. It's also host to community events and is a year-round gathering space for families.
The Schools: Typically zoned to:
Housing: Condos and townhomes around $250K–$450K; some newer single-family homes at higher price points.
Good Fit For: Young professionals, couples, and families who want walkability.
Similar Neighborhoods:
- Carmel Arts & Design District (IN)
- Downtown Naperville (IL)
- Decatur Square (GA)
Geist Reservoir Area Neighborhood
Families and retirees who want outdoor recreation and lake views
The Vibe: The Geist Reservoir Area offers a scenic lakefront lifestyle. Locals appreciate the views, but even more so, many dig in and get into boating and water recreation.
The Schools: Often zoned to:
Housing: Waterfront homes from $500K–$1.5M+; off-lake homes starting around $350K.
Good Fit For: Families and retirees who want outdoor recreation and lake views.
Similar Neighborhoods:
- Lake Minnetonka (MN)
- Lakeway (TX)
- Lake Oswego (OR)
Sandstone & Northeast Fishers Neighborhoods
Growing families looking for newer builds and strong schools
The Vibe: These are extremely family-oriented suburban neighborhoods. Part of this vibe comes from nice, newer, affordable subdivisions and cul-de-sacs. Part comes from the excellent schools and suburban amenities that create a holistic community.
The Schools:
Housing: Single-family homes, $325K–$600K depending on size and location.
Good Fit For: Growing families looking for newer builds and strong schools.
Similar Neighborhoods:
- Powell (OH)
- Overland Park east side (KS)
- Round Rock (TX)
West Fishers & Saxony Area Neighborhoods
Commuters who want easy highway access and suburban convenience
The Vibe: West Fishers and the Saxony area are home to a number of modest and upscale master-planned communities. It's also filled with retail centers for convenient local shopping. Finally, those who need to commute appreciate the easy access to I-69.
The Schools:
Housing: Mix of townhomes and larger single-family homes, $300K–$650K.
Good Fit For: Commuters who want easy highway access and suburban convenience.
Similar Neighborhoods:
- Dublin (OH)
- Plano east side (TX)
- Johns Creek (GA)
South Fishers Neighborhood
First-time buyers and families looking for value within Fishers
The Vibe: This is one of the most established neighborhoods in Fishers. The blocks are filled with mature trees and nicely manicured lawns. It's also home to some of the most affordable housing in the entire area.
The Schools:
Housing: Older single-family homes, $250K–$400K.
Good Fit For: First-time buyers and families looking for value within Fishers.
Similar Neighborhoods:
- Eden Prairie west side (MN)
- Cary older subdivisions (NC)
- Arlington Heights (IL)