Naples Proper & Old Naples: Deep Dive Guide (2025)
← Back to Naples / Collier County Overview
Naples Proper & Old Naples Overview
Naples Proper sits along the Gulf of Mexico and functions as the historic and cultural core of the Naples metro. This subarea includes Old Naples, Aqualane Shores, Coquina Sands, and parts of The Moorings.
Life here is shaped by proximity to the beach and strong seasonality. Housing decisions tend to prioritize location and access over size, and daily routines are influenced by traffic patterns and peak-season crowds.
Most people who live in this part of the area do so just to be close to the water and are comfortable with higher ownership costs and fewer practical conveniences.
What Daily Life Is Like
Daily life in Naples Proper is concentrated in a few well-defined areas rather than the entire city.
Many residents walk to the beach early in the morning, especially near Naples Pier and Lowdermilk Park, before visitor traffic increases. These areas are busiest early in the day and quieter by late morning.
Errands and social activity concentrate along Fifth Avenue South and Third Street South. People come here for coffee, dinner, small shops, and appointments. These streets are walkable, but they function as destinations rather than through-routes.
Most residents still drive for larger errands like grocery shopping or medical visits. Outside of the immediate downtown core, Naples Proper becomes car-oriented quickly.
Evenings tend to center on restaurants rather than nightlife although there is dancing! Bars exist and get plenty of traffic, but activity drops earlier than in larger cities, especially outside the winter season.
Worklife and Commutes
Most residents who work either do so locally or remotely.
Common employment includes healthcare, professional services, real estate, property management, and hospitality. Many residents are semi-retired, consulting part-time, or working remotely.
Commutes within Naples Proper are short, but traffic increases significantly during winter season, especially along US-41 and coastal access roads.
Housing Snapshot
Housing in Naples Proper is among the most expensive in Southwest Florida.
The area is dominated by older single-family homes and low-rise condos, many built decades ago. Teardowns and rebuilds are common, particularly closer to the water.
Inventory is limited, and renovations are often necessary. Flood exposure, elevation, wind insurance, and HOA fees materially affect monthly ownership costs.
Schools
Naples Proper is served by Collier County Public Schools.
Schools commonly referenced and often pursued by families living in or near Naples Proper include:
- Lake Park Elementary School— frequently cited for proximity and stability
- Gulfview Middle School — serves parts of central Naples
- Naples High School — one of the area’s long-established public high schools
That said, full-time family living is less common here. Many households are retirees or second-home owners. Families who prioritize schools often look north or inland for easier daily logistics.
Private schools are part of the decision set for some households, particularly at the middle and high school levels.
Who Naples Proper Works For
- Retirees and second-home buyers
- Buyers prioritizing beach access and dining
- Households comfortable with older housing stock
- People who value proximity over space
Tradeoffs to Know
- High purchase prices and insurance costs
- Heavy seasonal congestion
- Older homes that may require ongoing maintenance
- Limited space compared to inland communities
Areas and Pockets to Know
Old Naples
What it’s like: Walkable, historic, and close to the beach.
Who lives here: Retirees and second-home owners.
Similar nearby areas: Downtown Sarasota waterfront pockets.
Aqualane Shores
What it’s like: Waterfront, residential, and quiet.
Who lives here: High-net-worth buyers and long-term residents.
Similar nearby areas: Parts of The Moorings, but closer to the water.
Coquina Sands / The Moorings (southern edge)
What it’s like: Residential with beach access and older homes.
Who lives here: Full-time residents and retirees.
Similar nearby areas: Coastal neighborhoods north of downtown Sarasota.
Is Naples Proper a Good Fit?
Naples Proper works best for buyers who want coastal access and are comfortable with a smaller, more seasonal daily footprint.
It is a harder fit for families with young children, buyers seeking newer housing, or people who need easy weekday logistics.
Comparing Naples Proper with North Naples or Marco Island?
Save the areas you’re considering in LookyLOO so you can compare housing costs, school access, and daily routines before deciding.