Living on Staten Island: A Guide for Newcomers

What It's Like Here

Staten Island is New York City’s most suburban borough, separated by water and mindset. It offers large homes, quiet blocks, and big parks. Though it's part of the city, it feels more like New Jersey or Long Island. It’s a solid fit for families who want a yard and a driveway but still have access to Manhattan (even if it's a longer haul).


General Vibe
Low-rise, residential, and self-contained. You’ll find colonial homes, Italian bakeries, and public beaches—not something you usually associate with NYC. Some areas feel more like small towns than city boroughs.


Key Cities & Neighborhoods

  • St. George – Near the ferry, denser and more walkable
  • Tottenville, Great Kills, Annadale – Suburban sprawl with good schools and parks
  • Mid-Island (New Dorp, Dongan Hills) – Classic single-family home neighborhoods
  • North Shore – More urban and affordable, with mixed development

Who Lives Here

  • Families prioritizing space and affordability
  • City workers (police, fire, teachers)
  • Long-time Staten Islanders
  • Car commuters to Brooklyn or NJ

Things To Do

  • Staten Island Greenbelt, Snug Harbor Cultural Center
  • Staten Island Zoo, Staten Island Yankees games
  • Beaches (Midland, South Beach)
  • Historic Richmond Town, Staten Island Mall
  • Kayaking, hiking, nature preserves

Housing Snapshot

Housing Types:
Detached homes, duplexes, townhouses, and some apartments near the ferry

  • Typical Rents:
  • 1BR: $1,600–$2,400/month
  • 2BR: $2,200–$3,200/month

Purchase Prices:

  • Detached homes: $500K–$900K
  • Townhomes: $400K–$600K

Commute & Transit
Staten Island Ferry (free) to Lower Manhattan (~25 min ride). The Staten Island Railway connects local neighborhoods. Express buses to Manhattan. No subway to other boroughs. A car is almost a necessity.


Why It Works

  • Affordable homes with yards
  • Suburban lifestyle with NYC access
  • Strong public services and safety
  • Quiet, slower pace

What to Watch Out For

  • Isolated—long commutes to most of NYC
  • Not walkable in most areas
  • Limited nightlife or cultural scene
  • Not diverse in all pockets

Is Staten Island Right for You?
If you want the space and feel of suburbia but still want to pay NYC taxes and have access to the city when needed, Staten Island might be the best-kept secret, especially for families and commuters with cars.

If you want to expand your search to the greater metro, check out the LookyLOO Review of the New York City Metro Area.