Westerville, Ohio

The "Dry Capital"

Looklyloo Score: 91

View Full Profile

Uptown Westerville

Couples, Empty Nesters, Professionals

The Neighborhood Vibe:
The historic core of the city. Walkable streets, restaurants, coffee shops, and civic buildings create a small-town center.

Zoned Schools

  • Elementary: Emerson or Cherrington Elementary (varies)
  • Middle: Westerville Central Middle School
  • High School: Westerville Central High School

Housing Snapshot

  • Older single-family homes
  • Some apartments and condos near the core

Median Home Price

  • Mid-$500s to mid-$600s

Rental Snapshot

  • Limited
  • Some apartments and small homes

Why It’s Popular
Walkability, character, and community events.

Similar Neighborhoods
Old Worthington, Historic Dublin.

Highland Lakes

Families, DINKs

What It’s Like
A large planned community with beautiful winding streets, neighborhood lakes, and a private golf club. Some of the largest homes in all of Westerville and some of the nicest amenities in town.

Zoned Schools
- Elementary: McVay Elementary
- Middle: Walnut Springs Middle School
- High School: Westerville North High School

Housing Snapshot
- Larger single-family homes
- Built primarily in the 1990s and 2000s

Median Home Price: High-$600s to $800s to $1m+

Rental Snapshot: Rare, mostly owner-occupied

Similar Neighborhoods
- Muirfield Village
- Powell golf communities

Annehurst Neighborhood

Young Families, Professionals Commuting to Columbus

The Neighborhood Vibe:
A mid-century neighborhood that appeals to young families and professionals due to relative affordability and the nice blocks lined with mature shading trees. Professionals also appreciate the ease of commuting and quick access to Uptown and Alum Creek.

Zoned Schools
- Elementary: Annehurst Elementary
- Middle: Walnut Springs Middle School
- High School: Westerville North High School

Housing Snapshot
- Ranch and split-level homes
- Built mainly in the 1960s and 1970s

Median Home Price: Mid-$400s to low-$500s

Rental Snapshot
- Some single-family rentals
- Limited multifamily options

Similar Neighborhoods
- Colonial Hills (Worthington)
- Clintonville north

Northstar / Polaris Area Neighborhoods

Young Families, Professionals Working near Polaris

The Neighborhood Vibe
True suburban living amidst newer developments. Filled with young families in amenity-laden subdivisions. Also has professionals and couples in the multi-family housing. Quick access to Polaris and the shopping, dining, and entertainment options there.

Zoned Schools
- Elementary: Alcott or Genoa Elementary (varies)
- Middle: Genoa Middle School
- High School: Westerville Central High School

Housing Snapshot
- Newer single-family homes and townhomes
- Some apartment communities

Median Home Price: Mid-$500s to mid-$600s

Rental Snapshot
- More options than other parts of Westerville
- Apartments and townhomes available

Similar Neighborhoods
- Lewis Center
- Southern Delaware County suburbs

Hoover / Alum Creek Area Neighborhoods

Families, Outdoor-Focused

The Neighborhood Vibe
Quieter neighborhoods for families or professionals seeking a life near water and trails. Blocks and homes are much appreciated for those who want an outdoor lifestyle!

Zoned Schools
- Elementary: Pointview or Hanby Elementary (considered nearby)
- Middle: Walnut Springs Middle School
- High School: Westerville North High School

Housing Snapshot
- Single-family homes on larger lots
- Mix of older and newer builds

Median Home Price: Mid-$500s to mid-$600s

Rental Snapshot: Limited, mostly owner-occupied

Similar Neighborhoods
- Gahanna near Creekside
- Pickerington near parks